Latest News

(L-A Benoit / The McGill Tribune)
McGill, News

The Algemeiner ranks McGill fourth worst university for Jewish students

In late December, The Algemeiner – a Jewish newspaper in the United States – ranked McGill University as the fourth worst university for Jewish students in its first annual list of “The 40 Worst Colleges for Jewish Students” in North America.

The Algemeiner editors reviewed anti-Semitic actions on campuses according to the definition by the U.S. State Department. In the description of why McGill University is considered anti-Semitic, they highlighted a student who was targeted by anti-Israeli groups because of her advocacy, anti-Israel protests on campus, a Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement on campus, and The McGill Daily censoring pro-Israel content.

Hillel McGill is a Jewish student organization that supports the Jewish student population at McGill. Hillel McGill Vice-President Noah Lew, U1 Arts, said he does not believe that McGill deserves its poor ranking on the list.

“I strongly believe that the experience that many Jews have is excellent,” Lew said. “There are many Jewish organizations on campus: Hillel, Israel on Campus, [and] Chabad. [However,] many [Jewish students] refer to BDS as negatively affecting their experience.”

Melissa Freed, U1 Arts, who experienced anti-Semitic bullying in elementary school, said that she was surprised to see McGill University on this list, she has witnessed and experienced actions that could be misinterpreted as anti-Semitism.

“There’s very noticeable ‘Free Palestine’ graffiti on a building at the corner of Pine and Park,” Freed said. “Of course there are other factors too, the lack of kosher dining options, for example, that make it harder to be Jewish here than at other schools. However, I do suspect that the ranking was based with the belief that anti-Israel is the same thing as anti-Semitism.”

Unlike the beliefs of the article accompanying the ranking, Freed said she disagrees that BDS works against Jewish people.

“[BDS] is strictly political,” Freed said. “They oppose Israel’s occupation of Palestinian lands, and their actions are meant to further that message. It can certainly feel a bit hostile, especially for Jewish students who are more pro-Israeli occupation, but I do not feel physically threatened by the movement.”

According to Jonathan Boretsky, U1 Science, The Algemeiner ranking is misguided as it ignores important factors.


“I think the list is very misfounded,” Boretsky said. “The list should be titled ‘Most Active Anti-Israel Campuses with Sizeable Jewish Populations.’ I think McGill suffers from other problems unique to Montreal, but these problems are not in the spirit of the list and probably were not at all considered. For example, being a commuter school makes Hillel attendance difficult.”

A previous version of this article incorrectly spelled Chabad. The Tribune regrets this error.

Ask Ainsley, Student Life

Ask Ainsley: Should I break up with my partner for voting for Trump?

Dear Ainsley, 

My boyfriend voted for Trump, and I don’t support this. Should we break up?

Sincerely,

Perplexed about Politics (PAP)


Dear PAP,

As a pretty fierce liberal, upon reading your question my initial response was “absolutely.” I can’t count the amount of arguments I’ve gotten into with friends and acquaintances over Trump’s ideas. That being said, just because someone voted for Trump doesn’t make them a bad person. This decision is going to be a tough one for you, and you’ll have to decide what to do only after plenty of thought and consideration. To me, it seems like if you’re willing to break up with your boyfriend over who he voted for, there may be some underlying problems. Or, if you feel so strongly about the issue that it’s enough for you to reconsider the entire relationship, you might be better off apart. 

If you haven’t already, I think you need to have a straightforward, non-judgmental conversation with him to figure out why exactly he voted for Trump. You also need to consider his response to you when defending his political beliefs. Is he aggressive and dismissive of your concerns? Or is he considerate and open when sharing his opinions? To me, how he treats you during the discussion can be pretty indicative of the quality of your relationship and how much he cares about making it work. Additionally, when you have this conversation with him, try your best to avoid going on the defensive or getting mad at him. He’s far less likely to respond well if he feels like he’s being attacked for his beliefs. Even though it may seem paramount at the time, being the one who is “right” in a situation is not very important in a relationship in the long run. What is important, though, is open communication and mutual respect, regardless of what your beliefs may be.  

Though studies suggest that having similar interests in beliefs is important in a relationship, it’s also found that having differing personality traits can be similarly beneficial. Since you’ve already started dating, I imagine you do share some interests, despite having different political views. Politics isn’t everything, and plenty of people spend their entire lives without giving it more than a passing thought. Even if you are politically-inclined, there’s no one to say that you absolutely can’t make it work. Look at James Carville and Mary Matalin: The married couple are both high-powered individuals with years of experience in Washington as advisors to numerous presidents, but Carville is a staunch Democrat and Matalin is a steadfast Republican. If they can manage this as well as their 23-year-long marriage, I’d say nothing is truly impossible. 

It can be uncomfortable to be around someone who has different beliefs than you. The chasm between your ideas and theirs can sometimes mean you’re always feeling the need to defend your own. Nonetheless, it’s not all negative. If you’re only friends with like-minded individuals, your ideas may be stagnant and you risk being influenced by groupthink. Being exposed to new ways of looking at the world can be eye-opening, even if they don’t change your outlook.

The decision to break up with your boyfriend over differing political views is no doubt a challenging one. It should only come after healthy discussion, and a decision about your priorities. If your political beliefs are so different that the conflict outweighs the interests, traits, and passions you do have in common, parting ways early on in Trump’s presidency may be best for you both. However, if this difference is something you’re both willing to work through, that option is also on the table. 

 

Best of luck,

Ainsley

Football, Sports

NFL Awards

Most Valuable Player

Aaron Rodgers – Green Bay Packers

The King in the North has reclaimed his throne atop the NFC North. After a 4-6 start, Rodgers and his Green Bay Packers worked out the kinks and finished undefeated down the stretch. With a hodgepodge of receivers, Rodgers led the league in passing touchdowns and single-handedly saved the Packers’ season.

Offensive Player of the Year

Ezekiel Elliott – Dallas Cowboys

The rookie running back amassed 1,994 total combined rushing and receiving yards, leading the Dallas Cowboys into the playoffs with an NFC-best record of 13-3. With shades of  all-time rushing leader Emmitt Smith, Elliott’s performance has been nothing short of spectacular and should keep the Cowboys in Super Bowl contention for years to come.

Defensive Player of the Year: 

Damon “Snacks” Harrison – New York Giants

While not a household name, the New York Giants’ defensive tackle has quietly put together one of the best seasons of all time. He led all interior linemen with 86 tackles and finished the year with league leading 50 run stops, something only J.J. Watt in 2012 and 2013 has ever managed prior to Harrison.

Coach of the Year: 

Bill Belichick – New England Patriots

Missing the greatest quarterback of all time for a quarter of the season had no effect on Belichick’s New England Patriots. Dropping just one game without their all-star quarterback Tom Brady, the Patriots managed to rail off an NFL-best 14-2 record. There’s no breaking with tradition, Belichick deserves full credit for this incredible season.

Offensive Rookie of the Year

Dak Prescott – Dallas Cowboys

The fourth-round rookie quarterback was an instrumental part of the Dallas Cowboys’ success in 2016 while filling in for injured starter Tony Romo. His 23-4 touchdown-to-interception ratio would be incredible for anyone, let alone a player drafted with the intention of being a career backup. As it turns out, “Tim Tebow 2.0” was the most overlooked prospect of 2016.

Defensive Rookie of the Year

Joey Bosa – San Diego Chargers

Despite missing the first four games of the season due to contract issues and nagging injuries, the 2016 third-overall pick managed to accumulate 10.5 sacks this season. Bosa showed impressive speed and power coming off the edge and has become the sole bright spot on an otherwise dim Chargers team.

 

Private, Sports

Are eSports ‘real’ sports?

ESports have experienced a boom in popularity in recent years. Prize money, viewership, and exposure have all grown to previously unimaginable scales. With competitive gaming becoming commonplace, questions of legitimacy are still raised by its detractors, both by traditional sports fans and analysts alike.

ESports are competitive computer gaming leagues that showcase strategy and teamwork encompassing a variety of genres and game types. The most prominent leagues and circuits are made up of strategy games, such as Dota 2 and League of Legends, and first-person shooters, like Counter Strike: Global Offensive and multiple iterations of Call of Duty. 

The debate over the legitimacy of eSports centres in large part around whether the precision and strategy characteristic of competitive gaming is enough to compensate for the lack of physical activity. In response, proponents of eSports tote the necessity of extraordinary hand-eye coordination and refined motor skills. In an opinion piece for Al Jazeera, reporter and neuroscience student Tom Burns reported on the “extremely complex” nature of eSports, claiming the “careful planning, precise timing, and skillful execution” essential to competitive gaming make eSports worthy of recognition. Similar arguments have come up before  in support of different sporting events like poker and Formula One racing. However, their respective statuses as real sports remain ambiguous to this day. 

Additionally, viewership and industry revenue shows widespread growth. According to Newzoo–the foremost authority on eSports demographics–total revenue reached nearly $500 million with over 300 million viewers in 2016. Newzoo predicts that by 2019, eSports revenue could jump to well over $1 billion and viewership could reach 500 million worldwide. While the projected revenue would only make up a fraction of the billions of dollars mainstream sports bring in each year, the high rate of growth in competitive gaming may bring the industry into contention with the revenue figures seen in other sports industries.

Player compensation has also been feeling the effects of the industry’s growth. The top 100 highest earners in competitive gaming have made from just under $400,000 to over $2.7 million. The majority of these high salaries come from the Dota 2 circuit, where prize pools can generate over $9 million for first place teams and over $20 million in total. For comparison, the average MLB salary is $3.2 million, making the highest of eSports prizes seem merely average at best and demonstrating once again that eSports does not currently have the numbers to generate the same publicity as other sporting events.

While the figures may still not rival traditional athletics, first-hand testimony suggests eSports players train as hard as any other sport. According to a string of Tweets from Astralis, an eSports team from Denmark competing in the Counter Strike: Global Offensive circuit, each of its players spent almost half of 2016 away from home attending events and competing in 29 tournaments. As each competitive gaming tournament consists of multiple games, an eSports team may have the same time commitment to their events as a baseball or football team does, linking what some claim to be completely different types of competitive events.

With all factors considered, eSports will continue to grow despite its critics. The traditional notion of a ‘real’ sport may be centred on physical activity, but competitive gaming shows that the intense strategy, planning, and skill required to compete make eSports just as legitimate a sport as football or soccer.

Hockey, Sports

From the Cheap Seats: World Juniors exciting but struggles to get crowds

Hockey is a religion in Canada. People here go to ridiculous ends to watch the best game on earth–myself included. So as I headed over to the Bell Centre on Wednesday night to see Canada and Sweden face off in the semi-finals of the annual World Juniors tournament–contested between U20 national teams from around the world–I expected to be one of the tens of thousands of rambunctious fans filling up the stands. My expectations couldn’t have been further from reality. The arena was shockingly empty. Had this been a preliminary round game between Latvia and the Czech Republic, the attendance issues would have been understandable, but even Team Canada was unable to fill the seats.

Those who did show were treated to an exciting game with multiple lead changes ending in an upset 5-2 victory for the home side. Most of the meager crowd was checkered red and white, with blue and yellow polka dots marking pockets of Swedish fans. A giant Canadian flag was unfolded and passed around the rink, but struggled to stay afloat at some points where the crowd got thin. 

It’s difficult to pin down the main cause for such a low turnout. One reason could be the lack of a superstar player on Team Canada. Two years ago, for example, the talented Connor McDavid’s presence helped set records in attendance. But even without an individual standout, the tournament is still filled with future NHL players with all but one member already drafted. A lack of a rivalry between Sweden and Canada, despite both being powerhouses at the international level, could also have impacted interest in the game. While ticket prices started at $35, significantly less than a Canadiens game, some still considered it to be overpriced for U20. The Habs always have crazy fans willing to pay anything to go watch them play, which doesn’t seem to be the case for Team Canada at the junior level. Tournament organizers had already felt the need to lower their prices in an attempt to increase attendance.

Yet there’s another possible explanation that seems too paradoxical to be true: Canadians may be growing tired of hockey. With Canada hosting the World Cup of Hockey last summer and the NHL season in full swing, Canadians may not be looking for more hockey. A World Junior Championship game on a cold January weeknight could have been one hockey game too many for even the more dedicated fans.

If one thing is for sure, the fans who showed up to the game truly cared about their teams. These were some of the most passionate fans I have ever seen and they were certainly more crazed than those in attendance at an average Canadiens game. There were no tourists or fair weather fans there just for the experience-these were die-hard supporters and rink-rats from around the world.

Thankfully with Canada reaching the tournament final to play the United States the following night, attendance was at its highest for a thrilling 5-4 shootout win by the United States in arguably the best game of the tournament. Watching Team Canada play at any level is exciting, but at a certain point one can simply have too much hockey in his or her life. The International Ice Hockey Federation (IIHF) may need to continue lowering its prices in order to convince people to attend World Juniors games or find new marketing strategies to hype non-rival play. 

Arts & Entertainment, Books

Metatron brings emerging writers together

Literature can be much more intimate and private than visual or performance art. But for Concordia graduate Ashley Opheim, literature is the focal point of community. Her community is self-built: An independent publishing company called Metatron, established in 2013.  

When Opheim was studying creative writing at Concordia in 2012, she wondered why the literature community hadn’t flourished in the same way as music did in Montreal. She began organizing a series of reading events called “This is Happening Whether You Like It Or Not.” After many successful readings, Opheim and a group of other students were awarded a grant from Emploi Quebec that funded youth creative ventures. Opheim then turned her focus to growing Metatron into a company that published small chapbooks—staple bound paperbacks under 48 pages—rather than just event planning. 

Over the past 3 years, Metatron has published 15 books, 12 chapbooks, and organized 33 readings. The company distributes in small bookstores in Montreal—such as The Word on rue Milton —and Toronto, as well as selling their works online. 

For Opheim, what sets Metatron apart as a publishing company is its focus on nurturing young writers and validating their experiences. 

“There are so many talented writers [in Montreal] who are young and not technically qualified enough to have a book out with a bigger press,” Opheim explained.

 Opheim reminisced about Alt Lit, a—now defunct—online community that had inspired her around the time she began organizing the reading series.

“When I discovered [Alt Lit], it was kind of just writers who were writing, and they weren’t trying to be like anyone. They weren’t trying to be like Ernest Hemingway,” Opheim said. “They were kind of just like ‘this is my life and I’m gonna write a poem about toaster strudels,’ […] it wasn’t taking itself so seriously.”

This kind of writing continues to inspire Opheim. She feels that humour and authenticity of experience are at the heart of the work Metatron publishes.

“I feel like the books that we do are all relatable in a really fun way,” she explained. “I feel like people can open the books and see themselves in [them]. And I think that’s a really beautiful thing. [In] the world we live in, being able to see yourself in someone else, regardless of gender and race, is so powerful. And I don’t think there’s many things that exist in the world where that is a possibility.”

Opheim strongly believes that the most powerful writing comes from within, when a writer is true to how they feel. She is devoted to encouraging writers to express those feelings. 

“I feel like when people are able to write an emotion that is true, it becomes universal,” Opheim said. “As human beings, as nuanced and different as we are, I still think like there are experiences that are very similar for everyone [….]. Feelings of alienation are very prevalent in contemporary writing by younger writers.” 

Inclusivity and shared experience are the founding principles of Metatron. Opheim explains that for many artists, especially ones practicing the often private and introspective art of writing, a community is an essential motivating factor.

“Being part of a community like Metatron […] gives you an incentive and inspiration to keep on working,” she said. “[…] The people we actually publish, after their book comes out, I just literally see them blossom into these writers who are taking themselves more seriously and performing better.” 

Opheim’s goal of creating a literature scene in Montreal was possible largely due to what she calls the palpable “spirit of creativity” in the city. 

“I really feel that Montreal is the place to be if you’re a young creative,” Opheim said. “It’s such a fucking radical place.” 

McGill, News

$20 million donated to the Montreal Neurological Institute

On Dec. 16, the Montreal Neurological Institute (MNI) received a donation of $20 million from Larry Tanenbaum, the chairman of Maple Leaf Sports and Entertainment. The MNI is the largest specialized neuroscience research centre in Canada and, as part of McGill’s Faculty of Medicine, offers students a variety of research opportunities. The $20 million will sponsor the creation of an affiliated institute: The Tanenbaum Open Science Institute.

This new institute will represent the MNI in pursuing a mandate of ‘open science,’ a recent trend of promoting innovation by making research patent-free and openly available to other researchers. In addition to its world-leading research, the MNI will now be known globally as the first academic open science institute in the world.

‟Our digital world provides for unprecedented opportunities to leverage advances in technology to the benefit of science,” Tanenbaum said during the Dec. 16 announcement of the donation. “That is what we are celebrating here today: The transformation of research, the removal of barriers, the breaking of silos, and most of all, the courage of researchers to put patients and progress ahead of all other considerations.”

Tanenbaum hopes that research will be undertaken for the sake of overall knowledge rather than profit. Eric Sun, U2 Science, agreed that scientific networks are valuable.

“Sharing research is always good, coordinated efforts between communities are the reason why dangerous diseases like smallpox have been eradicated,” Sun said. “Discoveries are driven by dedicated scholars [who] spend their lifetimes in the lab.”

The McGill Chapter of Universities Allied for Essential Medicines (UAEM) Motion Regarding Global Access to Medicines Policy recently passed at the Students’ Society of McGill University (SSMU) council meeting on Nov. 17, 2016. The motion called for SSMU to support global access to medicines and lobby McGill to adopt a policy in favour of this. The purpose of the motion was to influence the university to adopt a patent-free policy so that drugs could be accessible in developing areas of the world. UAEM was pleased with how the donation will be used to encourage openness.

“The initiative will allow patents to not need to be made through universities anymore, which will make the process run more smoothly,” UAEM Co-Vice-President Media and Outreach Chloe Hogg said. “It is set up as an experiment to attract resources to McGill and to Montreal, while speeding up [much] needed innovation in basic research.”

Hogg said that there is still progress to be made, as facilitating developments in research does not necessarily mean that the final product will be globally accessible.

“Whether the innovation remains affordable and accessible for the greater public remains unclear,” Hogg said. “This is because [the initiative] only looks at basic research, which doesn’t go all the way to the final product that reaches the patient.”

Hogg also said that profits remain to be an important consideration when creating intellectual policies that mandate access.

Combat Sports, Sports

Ronda Rousey and the challenge of getting back up after a fall

Ronda Rousey’s long-anticipated comeback to UFC fighting came to a rapid halt in a 48-second technical knockout at the hands of defending UFC champion Amanda Nunes. The Dec. 30 fight marked another major setback in Rousey’s tumultuous career. After a meteoric rise to UFC and global stardom, Rousey lost her undefeated record and UFC Women’s Bantamweight title at the hands of Holly Holm in Nov. 2015. Rousey subsequently took 18 months off from UFC competition to recover and train before returning to the octagon last month. 

The mental strength to stay at the top of one’s game and rebound from defeat is an essential skill in any successful athlete’s repertoire. Rousey’s fall from UFC Bantamweight favourite and Hollywood darling to consecutive defeats mirrors the tumultuous journey many athletes face over their careers. These internationally lauded athletes can get overconfident in their matches or neglect to make adjustments and tweak their styles to keep opponents and newcomers off guard. Rousey’s questionable coaching has been widely criticized for both its legitimacy and strike heavy strategy; in particular, it makes her attacks more predictable and easier to prepare for. Additionally,  by taking advantage of technology for increased scouting, preparation, and film review of incredible sophistication, other athletes seem to have cracked the code of what made Rousey unbeatable.

For all athletes, the art of the comeback is incredibly tough to master. Watching Rousey fail in her initial attempt was relatable for athletes across the world. Whether being cut by a team, trying to overcome an injury, or facing mental roadblocks, athletes of all ages must constantly fight to remain competitive in their respective sports. Even for legends Michael Jordan and Muhammed Ali, comebacks can end in unfortunate failure.

Keeping confident with a winning record is much easier. In Rousey’s case, her wins became self-perpetuating–she believed she was incapable of losing. This confidence was only encouraged by the accolades and honours she received both inside and outside of the sports world. However, the true mental fortitude of an athlete is tested when they start losing. Serena Williams in particular has come to dominate women’s tennis because she remains poised even when she falls behind. Her 33 Grand Slam match victories [in which she was trailing by a set] show the importance of mental preparation for world-class athletes.

Whether or not there is a specific psychological formula to a successful comeback is up for debate. Intensity and consistency are two assets athletes must have, but maintaining these skills across matches is no guarantee–especially when faced with athletes perceived to be stronger or weaker in skillset. Some psychologists even believe that falling behind or losing a match can reignite the intensity and competitive spirit essential for a winning record. With this theory, losing can actually be a good thing if it jerks an athlete out of complacency.

With the mentality of a comeback in mind, Rousey is at a crossroads in her career. Perhaps other fighters have unlocked the secret to her style and have temporarily found ways to beat her until she can adapt and dominate them once more. Or, perhaps the “myth” of Rousey’s inability to be defeated has been crushed, giving other fighters confidence when they step into the octagon. Either way, Rousey can either lean into her losses and derive intensity from them or she can let her defeats define her. Many athletes have faced a similar choice, but for Rousey, the stakes are higher because of her celebrity status. Her response will either mark the end of her career or will solidify her as one of the greatest female athletes of all time.

McGill, News

McGill launches Summer Academy for high school students

For the first time, McGill Enrolment Services will run a program for high school students in Grades 10 and 11 called the “McGill Summer Academy.” The program will run for two weeks starting July 9, 2017. The Academy will allow students to stay in McGill residences, take courses with graduate students, and participate in organized extracurricular activities aimed at introducing students to the City of Montreal.

University Registrar and Executive Director of Enrolment Services Kathleen Massey said that the main goals of the program are for it to serve as a student recruitment initiative while offering an enriching academic, social, and cultural summer experience for young students.

“Having a lived experience at McGill will help the students decide whether McGill might be a good fit for them down the road,” Massey said. “We’ll also provide them with admission advising and information about the many academic and student life opportunities at McGill while they are here, giving them solid information they can use to develop longer-term academic plans.”

Massey said that the creation of the Academy was prompted by a high demand from prospective students.

“Our student recruiters have been asked by international students and their parents for many years whether McGill has a summer program […],” Massey said. “Many younger students would love the chance to come to McGill during the summer to experience the academic and cultural life of the university and Montreal.”

Interest in the program are prompted by fears students have provided about the unfamiliar experiences that university life presents. According to Grade 10 student Alisa Bressler, one of her main worries about entering university is handling the pressure to feel at home in a new environment.

“I think that a program that offers the experiences that will be presented to us in university early on would be very helpful,” Bressler said. “Particularly, I think spending time in residence would help a lot [with transitioning into university life].”

Enrolment Services began plans for the Academy in  2015. According to Massey, Desautels Master of Business Administration (MBA) student consultants performed market research and developed a sustainable revenue model for the program. The $3,565 cost of enrolment for the summer program covers housing, food, academic instruction, extracurricular programming, supervision, and health insurance.

Representatives from the Department of Political Science and the Integrated Program in Neuroscience (IPN) were enlisted to create the program’s two non-credit courses.

Dr. Joseph Rochford, director of the IPN, was contacted by Enrolment Services after research indicated that neuroscience was a primary topic of interest for potential students. Rochford and a team of graduate students began creating a syllabus, incorporating  a variety of topics in the field aimed at providing an introduction to McGill academics.

“The objective here is to sort of treat these high school students as if they were in university,” Rochford said. “It’s going to give them access and experience in terms of what to expect at the university level, how and the kind of content that’s being delivered, and give them the experience exactly of what it’s like to be an undergraduate student at McGill.”

Rochford said that McGill’s standing as one of the leading institutes in neuroscience research provides Summer Academy participants with a unique academic opportunity that will improve enrolment.

“If high school students are interested in pursuing a degree in neuroscience, [the Summer Academy] will really give them the idea that if they come and study here at McGill, they will be getting a world-class education,” Rochford said.

The cultural and social activities will be led by the Academy’s Team Leaders–current McGill students who will also provide supervision and mentorship.
The program will launch in July 2017 and registration will open Feb. 2017.

McGill, News

McGill semester start and end dates decided in accordance with Senate calendar guidelines

McGill’s Winter 2017 semester began on Jan. 4, before other Montreal universities including Concordia and Université de Montréal. This start date was initially set by the Committee on Enrolment and Student Affairs (CESA) and sent to the Senate for approval in May 2013. In their proposed calendar for this academic year, CESA made the winter break one day shorter so that the term could accommodate an exam prep day.

This was done in consideration of the 2011 Senate calendar guidelines, which recommend a break between Fall and Winter terms, a prep day or weekend prior to exams, and a 10-day exam schedule on top of McGill’s 13-week term–one of the longest among Canadian universities.

University Registrar and Executive Director Kathleen Massey said start and end dates are also intended to reduce housing costs for students, to allow students to begin summer jobs or internships at the beginning of May.

The Students’ Society of McGill University (SSMU) Vice-President (VP) University Affairs Erin Sobat said that the start date is understandable given the constraints of term guidelines.

“While I think it would definitely be preferable for most students and professors to begin classes next week, McGill's start date is consistent with many other universities in Canada,” Sobat wrote in an email to The McGill Tribune. “In addition, December final exams ended slightly earlier this year to give everyone at least a two-week break. Since it's the Add/Drop Period until Jan. 17, many students won't come back until [the weekend of Jan. 7] anyway.”

Sobat said that the university guidelines do not allot a time for a Fall break.

“There's a clear inconsistency between the Fall and Winter terms when it comes to time off,” Sobat wrote. “Part of this is due to tighter timelines in the Fall with the December holiday break. However, it's also a historical difference. Most courses used to operate on a full-year schedule and so assessments were more spread out. Since that's changed, I think the Fall term has become more intense for many students, particularly first-years, and the mid-term and November periods, when the days get shorter, can be particularly challenging.”

In 2015, a working group was established by Deputy Provost (Student Life and Learning) Ollivier Dyens in response to a SSMU request to adopt a Fall reading break. In its June 2015 report on its findings, the working group  proposed a break of two days that would be added to Canadian Thanksgiving. To incorporate the proposal, the report noted that trade-offs, such as commencing classes before Labour Day, were necessary to maintain the 13-week term.

The working group also reasoned that the Fall term is particularly difficult for students, evidenced by  McGill Health Services’ reported increase in demand over the last five years in October and November.  Further, students have overwhelmingly supported a Fall break. In a 2015 survey conducted by Enrolment Services, 71.5 per cent of respondents supported the initiative. The proposal was also supported by major student associations, such as the SSMU and the Arts Undergraduate Society (AUS).

Julia Thome, U2 Arts, said that the start date had interrupted her experience of the holidays.
“The early return wasn't altogether awful,” Thome said. “But it did complicate my family's travel plans and the short break made the holiday season more stressful than relaxing.”

Read the latest issue

Read the latest issue